My father, who was a lifelong Republican died in May 2016. He loved Ronald Reagan when he was a president; his home was sprinkled with books and other Reagan paraphernalia. He also donated a significant amount of money to the Young America Foundation, a conservative youth movement within the Republican Party. Dad was a businessman and his allegiance to the GOP largely had to do with its pro-business stance. On social issues such as abortion and gay marriage, he was more of a moderate. Back in the day when there was such a thing as a moderate Republican and he would have been in that category.
When I was growing up in the era of Civil Rights and the Vietnam War, Dad and I had many conversations about current events. We rarely agreed on the issues — which ranged from the war to racism to the role of business in foreign countries like Mexico and South Africa — but we always debated respectfully. We argued our positions passionately and though we had differing perspectives, I always felt respected by him, even though I knew my more progressive views bothered him.
Over the past four years, I often wondered what my father would have thought of Donald Trump. As a pro-business Republican, I would guess Dad would have liked things like the Trump tax cut and his plans to bring manufacturing back to the U.S. However, my father was not crass. He did not berate or demean those with whom he disagreed. And I think within his business-oriented, pro-capitalist worldview, he was basically a moral and ethical individual who valued honest hard work. He might have voted for Donald Trump in 2016, but I have to believe Trump’s arrogant dehumanizing vulgarity and his unwillingness to think beyond his own self-interest would have turned my father off.
Over the past weeks since the November 3rd election, many lifelong Republicans have either lost their mind or their integrity or both. Their crusade to overturn a free and fair election has been nothing short of ludicrous, pathetic, and outrageous. I would expect as much from Donald Trump and Rudy Giuliani, but the 19 state attorneys general and 126 Congressional representatives who took a meaningless case to the Supreme Court, both enrages and baffles me. Moreover, even before the election, some Republicans seemed hell-bent on doing anything they could to steal the election from putting out fake ballot boxes in California to threatening vote counters and berating governors who would not overturn an election that went Biden’s way. I even heard electors who had to ask for a police escort when they went to cast their votes this past Monday.
And as a result polls show that upwards of 70% of registered Republicans think that somehow the election was stolen from Trump even though Trump’s Director of Cybersecurity said this was the safest election in U.S. history; of course he was fired the day after he said that. Apparently, for many Republicans, their party has become a gang of Trump-worshippers who not only reject President-elect Biden, but also the very democratic process that elected him.
I cannot believe my father would stand for this. As former Justice official under Presidents Reagan and Bush, Murray Dickman wrote “Republicans, we’re better than this. He goes on: “What has become of my party. After a career spent in Pennsylvania and national politics as a Republican, I’m disappointed to see some Republicans’ behavior in the aftermath of the election.” I think my father would agree.
In one sense I could care less what happens to the Republican party, but it deeply concerns me that Republicans have fallen into some strange absurdity following a man who is a sociopathic narcissist of the highest order. That can only spell doom for those who follow this Pied Piper over the cliff. On the other hand, these last several weeks have shown that there is a basic set of ethics and morality upon which U.S. democracy rests. When those ethics are spurned and morals degraded, democracy is threatened. My hope is that the Democratic party will not follow suit and take on the same tactics. I still hold to what Michelle Obama said four years ago: “When they go low, we go high.”
I have to believe that my father would have responded to the outcomes of the election up and down the ballot, some of which his party won and others that they lost, with the kind of respect and equanimity he granted me in our many after-dinner political debates when I was growing up. Those seem to be values that the current Republican leadership has trashed and rejected. While I wish my Dad were here so I could hear his reaction, on the other hand, I am glad he did not live long enough to see the country, party, and democracy he loved be debased as it has been over the past four years. Rest in peace, Dad.
Respectfully disagreeing is s lost virtue these years. It was great to read that while you and your father disagreed on some things you were still able to share your thoughts with each other.
I agree with your sentiments and at the same time left with the question of wha he would done during this election? Part of the challenge is that few of us cross the aisle even if we feel left out of our own party. The Clinton machine might have disturbed me but I wasn’t going to vote for a Republican because of it. I get that voting and following the cult worship over a cliff are two different things. I wish for more integrity among other Republican leaders for the sake of our democracy. As I do for many Democrats also.
Of course, brother. We have such similar experiences.
My father and grandparents were dedicated Republicans.
And I argued intensely with my dad.
And I wonder how he, as a loyal Republican would have stuck with them through the travesty of the last four years. I’m sure he would have somehow stuck it out.
And I would have enjoyed talking to him about, but even more to my mom who was more flexible and compassionate.
Thank you Drick for the courage to say what’s so troublesome on the political front. It really does feel like a war zone. What is breaking my heart and disturbing my hope is that so many Christians, especially white evangelicals (which I also used to be) are still willing to support 45. It honestly makes my brain explode. If our first Black president had done any of the corrupt things (which are most of thee “things) 45 has done none of them would be or would have been silent. It’s really unexplainable from a Biblical perspective. Thank you for keeping the torch burning and telling the truth with admirable courage.
Hi Mr. Boyd,
So happy I looked this topic up, as it has been nagging at me lately.
Our family discussions probably mirror yours.
Rather than drag you through conversation details, I will try to get to the chase:
My father stood behind every Republican president, even Nixon. (He brought his little Sony TV to work to watch the impeachment hearings. He was a small business owner.)
I don’t know how he would have voted in the last election and this one. But, I do know that Barbara Bush in an interview with her biographer said that she had changed parties…circa 2016.
I do think that my father, veteran, independent business man, community fundraiser, local volunteer on many boards and supreme believer in making community work on a local level would have thought long and hard about voting for Pres.Trump. I can’t speak for my father now. He had his own way of doing that.(LOL)
But, I just can’t imagine he would be a Trump supporter, even listening to Fox News.